History of the A's

 
 

The Roaring Twenties

 
 

The issue of professionalism in lacrosse had long been a source of controversy as the "simon-pure" amateurs were viewed by many as possessing some higher nobility than the players who received monetary gain for their services. But in the early boom years of the sport when gate receipts were high and there was money to be made, many players happily received a healthy stipend as lacrosse mercenaries.

With the collapse of the openly professional teams and the rise of the Ontario Amateur Lacrosse Association, the old rigid thinking of amateurism took a stranglehold on the game in the province. That’s not say there still wasn’t some money to be earned but now teams carefully took a more under-the-table approach to the subject.

Through the twenties the St. Catharines Athletics were trying vainly to recapture some of the past magic both on the field and at the box office. But the team just wasn’t winning as they were before and the fans weren’t as captivated in their double blues as in the past. The A’s would seem to be on the verge of a breakthrough in 1924, but an unexpected reprimand by the O.A.L.A. for the use of long-time Athletic, Percy Oille, would ultimately lead to the decision to fold the team.

After a hiatus of four years, the team returned to action in front of fairly good crowds and with Oille back in the lineup. But in the following year of 1929, the now losing Athletics couldn't draw any fan interest in the city and they made the regrettable decision to fold the team after just four games. The 1920’s were certainly a tumultuous period for the Athletics and the decade closed without a senior team in operation.

The demise of the proud Athletics in '29 was really a picture of the entire sport of field lacrosse in a microcosm. It seemed that our old favourite summer pastime was dying everywhere in Canada, and passionate observers of the sport were pointing to the situation in St. Catharines as symptomatic of a larger issue.

During the twenties, the population of St. Catharines grew to 23,000, the first traffic light was installed at the corner of Queen and St. Paul Streets, the N. S. & T. streetcar network was at its peak, Burgoyne Woods was gifted to the city from the estate of W. B. Burgoyne, and the St. Catharines Collegiate was built on the site of the former Athletics Lacrosse Grounds.

The Athletics scrapbook for this era includes:

July 26, 1920 "Blue ribbon lacrosse event"
May 27, 1921 Pim's seven goals spoils A's return
June 22, 1921 "The home of lacrosse"
July 16, 1921 Eight is enough against the Duffs
July 21, 1921 Old Boys return for "Old Home Week"
July 3, 1922 The last game at the "old corner lot"
July 11, 1922 Athletics move into "temporary" home
August 7, 1923 Athletics and Dufferins go down to the wire
June 25, 1924 Exciting Athletics on the rise
July 3, 1924 Athletics go out with a bang
October 21, 1924 Juniors capture Desborough Cup
September 26, 1926 Recalling the old corner lot (a poem)
May 25, 1928 A's return to a good crowd
September 4, 1928 "the cheers could be heard for miles"
May 23, 1929 A day filled with promise
June 20, 1929 Athletics go out with a whimper

SCRAPBOOK

HOME